I first heard of To Gaze Upon Wicked Gods by Molly X. Chang when the news of Cait Corrain's review bombings hit the Booktok and Booktube rounds. The beautiful cover caught my eye, but since it was often criticized as romanticizing colonization, I was hesitant to pick it up.
However, I have a series I am querying that also deals with an attempt at colonization: the villain is invading the main character's lands with the intent to conquer, occupy, and settle them. While intentionally looking for newer comps that might encompass the same audience and hit some of the same themes, TGUWG came up more than once. When I spotted it at my local indie bookstore, I grabbed it and decided I needed to read it.
I am so glad I did.
TGUWG is a story of power dynamics and the power of expectations. The main character and narrator, Ruying, is caught in a web of what is expected of her by society, by her family, by the technologically advanced Romans who occupy Pangu, and her own expectations of the people in her life and in her world.
Expectations can warp our entire view of a person. They affect how we respond. During the Korean War, certain US POWs defected to North Korea. Studies in the 1970s by Dr. Frank Wesley at Portland State University found that most of these men were held at one POW camp. Additionally, they had all been taught to expect the North Koreans to be monsters. All the men had, as part of their training in the US military, been told how terribly they would be treated and tortured if caught. But once they were, that didn't happen. At that particular camp, the Koreans treated the prisoners with kindness and dignity. The juxtaposition of expecting the worst only to be shown kindness helped shift their view on Koreans and North Korea's cause. (Discussion of this can be found here.)
In Ruying's world, she expects her childhood friend, Baihu, to be loyal to Pangu and their people. His choice to dress like a Roman, involve himself in them, and provide the drugs that have devastated the population are, to her, the deepest betrayal. Conversely, her first encounter with Antony is witnessing him being compassionate even though she expects all Romans to be cruel. Antony further breaks down her expectations for him throughout the book. When she discovers his identity, she again expects cruelty or death but is offered enough solace and understanding that it disarms her. The conflict between her expectations and the other characters' actions becomes a deep part of why she makes the choices she does. I found it particularly well done, and my fascination with the contrast kept me reading.
I also think the book itself suffered from the power of expectations. On social media, it seems to have been classed as a fantasy romance. I often saw it described as enemies-to-lovers, a currently popular trope. Some reviewers loved it because they saw it as a version of that. Others disliked it for the same reason, especially because it would mean that the book's endgame would be a happily-ever-after between Ruying and Antony. Since Antony is not just from the colonizing people, but a prince of their land, some readers found it toxic or distasteful. If that were the case, it wouldn't be a healthy romance or relationship.
I didn't go into the book blind. I had read and listened to reviews, and that may have affected how I viewed the story. It never felt like a romance to me, and certainly didn't by the end of the book. Different marketing or different word-of-mouth might have shifted the conversation away from romance to other themes in the book.

No comments:
Post a Comment