Tuesday, January 28, 2025

Why Do We Hate Prologues?

 Because we grew up in the 80s and 90s and read David Eddings.



Okay, he's not the only culprit, but there was this era in fantasy writing where, I swear, all the authors looked at Tolkien and the Silmarillion and decided that they needed something like that too. Instead of putting it in a separate book so readers could pick it up or not, they shoved it into a prologue detailing thousands of years of the history of their world.

I completely understand the urge to show everyone all our wonderful world-building. I've got bits and pieces of worlds that, tragically, no one knows because it wasn't important to the story. Alas. 

Those prologues were a place to infodump. No one wants to read that before they get to the story. We don't care about the world until we love the characters. Infodumps in prologues are as bad as infodumps anywhere else. Go ahead and write it, but don't shoehorn it into the beginning of your book.

Other prologues trade the infodump for action, but try too hard to be mysterious. Too often it feels like the author is trying to emulate movies, where the viewer is thrown into action with no explanation. I recall the beginning of a barbarian movie I watched as a child. The unnamed barbarian emerges from his tent and announces, "It is time!" He rides off into the storm, there's shuffling and screaming, mostly off camera because it's 1987, and then the same man announces, "It is done!"

This opening was so effective that it became a running joke in our family to announce "It is time" anytime we went to the bathroom. 

You don't want your prologue to be the bathroom joke. 

It's hard to connect to a piece of writing when every character is generic: the man, the woman, the child, the old crone. If the scene is important to the book, and there's a decent reason to not make it chapter 1 (it happens long before the main story, far away from the main story, or includes characters who aren't the main character), it's acceptable to give the people in the scene names. Please. 

Prologues don't seem to be as anathema as they were twenty years ago when I first started reading industry blogs, but they still need to add to the experience of the story, not detract from it.

No comments:

Post a Comment

Tropes: The Odd Couple

Tropes are the basic ingredients of stories that flavor the plot and characters. They're the literary difference between chocolate cake...