Thursday, January 23, 2025

How Dark a Gray

 The morally gray hero, antihero, protagonist, and love interest is the character of the hour. Everyone is in love with characters whose moral compass doesn't point true north (or in some cases, lost its needle). 

In fantasy circles, there's a trend towards the morally gray that insists they must be murderers and, unfortunately, not too concerned with consent. There are quite a few other ways for a character to be morally gray. 

Gray is, by nature, an ambiguous thing. White and black are definable, but gray is the vast area in between. For a book character to be morally gray, they must engage in acts that transgress both the accepted morals of their fictional world and the morals of the reader's culture. These tend to be acts that are either taboo or that actively harm others: murder, theft, fraud, adultery, rape/sexual assault, incest . . . most cultures, both real and fictional, consider those wrong on some level, or at least give lip service to them being immoral. 

A character doesn't have to engage in all of those to be morally gray. In some cases, they just need to be selfish and willing to skirt the law. Exhibit A is Duke from the series Haven (based on the Stephen King story The Colorado Kid). Duke is not a murderer or a thief. He's a ladies man, but it's all consensual. He's still morally gray, though. He's a smuggler and lies to both law enforcement and Audrey, the main character. When the chips are down, Duke is out for himself. He also has lines he won't cross, or has to be compelled to cross. Duke's character arc is interesting because he grows less selfish while still being morally gray. The good guy choosing the selfless thing doesn't mean as much as the selfish character choosing it. 

Having boundaries makes a gray character far more interesting. He'll lie and charm his way into society to steal something, but he's no murderer (like Neal Caffrey in White Collar). He might dangle someone over a precipice to interrogate them or give them quite a beat down, but he doesn't kill and won't use guns (like Batman). He'll commit fraud and theft, but only from the rich and powerful, usually to help the little guy (like the team in Leverage). Maybe he'll leave a swath of murder and mayhem in his wake but treats his lady like a queen. And, as is popular, maybe he doesn't ask what she wants in the bedroom, or if she wants it at all. 

Those are all different shades of gray. Neal is a classic loveable rogue, so not very dark. Batman is a vigilante, and how dark he is depends on who's looking. Not dark at all to some, quite dark to others. Once a character is comfortable (or enthusiastic) about murder, they've gone several shades past those two. No matter how dark, the engaging part of the character is the glimmers of light in that darkness. The one person they'll sacrifice themselves for, the one cause they're willing to die for, the moment they try to make amends to another character for past wrongs. That's the moment we really love the smuggler, the thief, the mercenary, and the murderer: when they are choosing a moment of white out of a life of gray. 

No comments:

Post a Comment

Tropes: The Odd Couple

Tropes are the basic ingredients of stories that flavor the plot and characters. They're the literary difference between chocolate cake...